From the department of Pathology, Northwestern university Feinberg institution of Medicine, Chicago, Illinois.

You are watching: How many levels of surgical pathology are there


From the department of Pathology, Northwestern university Feinberg institution of Medicine, Chicago, Illinois.
From the room of Pathology, Northwestern university Feinberg college of Medicine, Chicago, Illinois.
From the room of Pathology, Northwestern college Feinberg school of Medicine, Chicago, Illinois.
From the department of Pathology, Northwestern college Feinberg institution of Medicine, Chicago, Illinois.
From the room of Pathology, Northwestern college Feinberg institution of Medicine, Chicago, Illinois.
From the room of Pathology, Northwestern university Feinberg school of Medicine, Chicago, Illinois.
From the department of Pathology, Northwestern college Feinberg institution of Medicine, Chicago, Illinois.

Audrey Deeken-Draisey, Allison Ritchie, Guang-Yu Yang, Margaret Quinn, Linda M. Ernst, Ajda Guttormsen, Gyongyi Ella Simionov, Kruti P. Maniar; present Procedural terminology Coding for Surgical Pathology: A Review and One scholastic Center"s suffer With Pathologist-Verified Coding. Arch Pathol rap Med 1 December 2018; 142 (12): 1524–1532. Doi: https://doi.org/10.5858/arpa.2017-0190-RA

Download citation file:


The existing Procedural ax (CPT) system is a standardized number coding system for reporting clinical procedures and services, and also is the basis because that reimbursement that health care providers by Medicare and other third-party payers. Accurate CPT coding is therefore critical for suitable compensation as well as for compliance through Medicare policies, and erroneous coding may result in ns of earnings and/or far-reaching monetary penalties because that a hospital or practice.


To provide a testimonial of the history, existing state, and basic principles of CPT coding, in particular as it uses to the exercise of surgical pathology, and also to existing our experience with initiating a new system of pathology involvement in the review and verification of CPT codes, including the most typical codes that require alteration in our exercise at the moment of sign-out or post–sign-out auditing.


Review the English language literature, published CPT sources from the American clinical Association and other professional organizations, and billing top quality data native a solitary institution.


Although the ideal extent of doctor involvement in CPT coding is a issue of some debate, a multidisciplinary strategy involving both health care providers and professional coders shows up to it is in the best way to attain accuracy.


Standardized procedural coding systems have actually been vital component of the clinical system since the beginning of present Procedural terminology (CPT) in 1966, and also in particular since the adoption of the health and wellness Insurance Portability and also Accountability plot in 1996. A quick historical synopsis is herein provided.


The an initial edition that CPT was released by the American clinical Association (AMA) in 1966, complying with the facility of Medicare by the us Congress.1,2  This version noted a 4-digit coding system generally for operation procedures, with restricted inclusion of other medical and laboratory services. The aim to be to determine if together a system would be useful for medical insurance companies and also for statistical research study in health care.1,2  Three subsequent editions were released in the 1970s, broadening the CPT system to include diagnostic and therapeutic solutions in all medical specialties, and additionally switching come a 5-digit coding system.1  The right now used 4th edition was initially published in 1977 and has been updated annually because 1983.1,3 


In 1996, the us Congress spread the health and wellness Insurance Portability and Accountability act (HIPAA). Among numerous other measures, this act required the department of Health and Human services to identify a set of national standards to paper medical services and also procedures because that the digital exchange of health care information.1,2  In response, the AMA established a job to revise CPT in stimulate to meet the needs for being called as this mandated standard.2  This endeavor proved successful, and in the year 2000, the Centers because that Medicare and also Medicaid solutions (CMS) designated CPT as the national coding standard for reporting physician and also other health care services and procedures.1,2  adoption of this device by every health care plans and providers that use electronic exchange the health care information was forced by 2003.1 


The evolution and expansion that CPT codes was paralleled through an evolution in the system for maintaining and updating present codes, i m sorry is the responsibility of the CPT Editorial Panel. Initially, the dashboard operated under a closed-door policy; however, in 1992, a more open procedure was adopted. The 17-member panel is composed of rotating members with representation from physicians, nonphysician health treatment providers, payers, and the American Hospital Association.2,4  The panel meets 3 times every year to evaluate every code readjust proposals, and also is aided by a bigger body that CPT torture who consist of the CPT Advisory Committee. The advisory committee members are generally physicians nominated through national medical specialty cultures in the AMA house of Delegates.4  The duties of the advisors encompass submitting code adjust proposals, commenting ~ above code readjust proposals submitted by others, providing literature about efficacy and also appropriateness of new procedures and also the work associated therein, promoting education of committee membership, and functioning as liaisons between the panel and the members" respective medical specialties.2,4  In accordance through the AMA"s open policy with regard to CPT code changes, the AMA website offers an application process for CPT code revisions, which might be it is registered by a selection of parties, consisting of individual physicians, medical specialty societies, and third-party payers.4 


There room 3 category of CPT codes. The bulk of codes fall under group I, and any brand-new Category i codes must satisfy several certain criteria: (1) any necessary tools and/or drugs have approval or clearance indigenous the united state Food and also Drug Administration, (2) the procedure/service is perform by countless health treatment providers transparent the country, (3) the frequency at which the procedure/service is carry out is regular with its intended clinical use, (4) the procedure/service is continual with current medical practice, and also (5) over there is sufficient literature documenting the clinical efficacy that the procedure/service.5  group I is separated into 6 sections: evaluation and also management, anesthesiology, surgery, radiology, pathology and laboratory, and also medicine. Group III codes space a temporary set of password that do not yet accomplish criteria to be authorized as classification I codes.6  They allow for a procedure/service to be tracked in bespeak to identify the level of usage nationally. After ~ 5 years, either this codes are determined to accomplish criteria to be converted to group I or they are retired.6  group II codes space optional supplemental tracking codes provided for performance measurement, and also they permit data collection concerning quality of care.5 


The 5-digit number CPT codes because that the specialty the pathology span from 80048 come 89356, with specimens in operation pathology extending from 88300 to 88309. These correspond to 6 level of interpretation: level i (88300), gross examination only; level II (88302), gross and microscopic check to check identification and also the lack of disease; and levels III–VI (88304, 88305, 88307, and 88309), gross and also microscopic examination with increasing levels of physician work.3  The unit of company for surgical pathology is the specimen, i m sorry is characterized as a tissue that is submitted as a separately identifiable sample requiring separation, personal, instance interpretation.7  In order to be coded individually, specimens should be evaluated individually by the pathologist in the last report. A number of specific rules use for the specific assignment of CPT codes because that surgical pathology. The CPT hands-on lists particular specimens under every surgical pathology level that should always be coded as that level (eg, a fallopian pipe for sterilization is always level II <88302> and also an adrenal resection is always level V <88307>). Unlisted specimens should be coded based on a decision of physician work-related involved. Lot of tissue types received in the exact same container might merit different CPT codes, also when eliminated en bloc, conversely, others space grouped together into one code also when got in lot of containers, based on bundling and also unbundling rules. A few of this rules space addressed in this manuscript; the leader is also referred to the many substantial resources obtainable from the AMA and also other institutions for appropriate selection of CPT password in pathology and also other specialties.3,8 


Currently, the primary use that the CPT mechanism is the report of clinical procedures and services to both public and private insurance allowance companies. The amount paid by Medicare because that a given company (ie, a particular CPT code) is figured out by CMS, usually based on recommendations it is registered by the loved one Value scale Update Committee, i beg your pardon was developed by the AMA.6,9  The relative Value scale Update Committee, which has 31 physicians and 300 clinical advisors from multiple specialties, makes recommendations based upon assessment of the resources required to provide each clinical service. The resulting resource-based relative value range is used not only by CMS but also by many other payers.10  The resources forced to carry out each organization are divided into 3 components, each of which is assigned family member value systems (RVUs): medical professional work, practice expense, and also professional liability insurance. Top top average, the physician job-related component accounts because that 51% the the full relative worth for a offered service, the practice expense component because that 45%, and the skilled liability component because that 4%.6,10  yes, really Medicare payments to medical professionals are based upon the physician Fee Schedule, which is developed by a formula making use of the resource-based relative value scale, geographic practice expense indexes, and a conversion factor.6,7,11  various other payers making use of the resource-based relative value range as a basis for payment might use various conversion factors or other approaches to convert relative value units to payment.6  that note, the medical professional Fee Schedule conversion element was previously changed annually utilizing the problem Sustainable development Rate formula, which demanded regular activity by congress to stop unsustainable cuts yet which will certainly be removed under the Medicare accessibility and CHIP Reauthorization act of 2015 (MACRA), which creates a an ext performance-based mechanism of incentives and also penalties.12 


In pathology, compensation for a company is usually split into a physician skilled fee component and a technological component. The physician skilled fee ingredient is spanned under the Medicare part B doctor Fee Schedule because that both inpatients and outpatients.7  Coverage the the technological component relies on the provider and patient setting. Because that hospital-based services, the technical component is bundled into prospective payment plan that administer a single fixed payment based upon the diagnosis-related group (inpatients, Medicare component A) or the Ambulatory Payment category (hospital-based outpatient services, Outpatient Prospective Payment System).7,13  because that non–hospital-based outpatient providers, the technological component is paid according come the Clinical laboratory Fee Schedule under Medicare component B; starting in 2018, the fees schedule for clinical laboratory tests will be based upon median private payer rates.14  Table 1 offers the current Medicare compensation for various commonly used codes in surgical pathology.15 


2017 Medicare Compensation for commonly Used existing Procedural terminology (CPT) codes in operation Pathology




A 2nd system of standardization codes, the Healthcare typical Procedure Coding system (HCPCS), is likewise required for billing particular services because that beneficiaries of Medicare and also some other insurers.16  developed in the 1980s, HCPCS is administered through CMS, and is divided into 2 subsystems. Level I consists entirely that the CPT password system, there is no modification. Level II is offered to recognize products, supplies, and also services that room not consisted of in the CPT codes, for example ambulance services, long lasting medical equipment, and also supplies used exterior a physician"s office.16  The codes space alphanumeric, each starting with a solitary alphabetic letter complied with by 4 numeric digits. Just a couple of HCPCS level II codes are applicable come pathology, and also these consist mostly of “G-codes,” developed for procedures/services because that which an suitable CPT password does not exist every the determination of CMS. For example, once billing a Medicare beneficiary because that prostate needle biopsies, HCPCS level II password G0416 is used singly, regardless of the variety of individual biopsies, rather than 88305 for each individual biopsy.8 


In particular situations, amendment of CPT or HCPCS codes might be necessary. The modifiers are 2 characters in length (numeric for CPT modifiers and alphabetic or alphanumeric for HCPCS modifiers), and also are added to the finish of the CPT or HCPCS code. They offer to provide extr information regarding special scenarios that may apply to a details instance the a company or procedure. Because that example, they may show that only the physician professional fee ingredient or only the technical component is being billed, the a company was listed by an ext than one provider or in much more than one location, that the degree or intricacy of the organization was much more or less than usual, the a service was listed more than once in a solitary day, or the a company was carry out by a resides or other under teaching doctor supervision.3,8,16  typical modifiers supplied in pathology include the CPT full 26, which suggests that only the physician skilled fee component is being billed (eg, because that hospital-based services), and also the HCPCS comprehensive TC, which shows that only the technical component is gift billed.8 


Overall, the usage of CPT coding has systematized the procedure of documenting and categorizing medical procedures accurately and efficiently, and remains the basis because that compensation the clinical and laboratory services. Thus, adequate knowledge of the existing CPT device is an important for any kind of practicing physician and also laboratory. In the succeeding sections, we detail our scholastic center"s experience with CPT billing in operation pathology, consisting of the current implementation that pathologist-verified billing, and also discuss the issues relevant to medical professional involvement in the CPT coding procedure in general.


In may of 2015, the department of pathology at our academic hospital denote a new anatomic pathology billing process, by which CPT password are verified by attending pathologists at the time of case sign-out. The reasons for this change were manifold, but were primarily aimed at improving coding accuracy and timeliness.


Prior come this, pathologists had no involvement in selecting or verifying the CPT codes connected with their cases. Every specimen form automatically created a CPT code or collection of password at the time of accessioning. Codes to be audited, corrected, and bulk proved by experienced billing and gross room staff. One trouble with this system was that instance charges were often initially verified under the name of the pathologist to whom the specimen was initially accessioned, and not have to the pathologist who eventually verified the case, which produced extra occupational at the ago end for important corrections. An additional issue was that technical and also professional fees were verified together, after ~ the situation was finalized, which sometimes caused loss the revenue from so late billing the the technological component. Additionally, discussions in between the staff auditing and verifying the billing and the pathology who proved the instance were minimal.


In the new system, the early CPT codes room still instantly assigned at accessioning based upon the specimen type. However, as soon as a pathologist traction up a situation in the anatomic pathology laboratory info system (PathNet, Cerner Corporation, phibìc Kansas City, Missouri), a separate window with the currently connected CPT codes instantly pops up. Once the pathologist verifies the case, the professional materials of the CPT codes are also automatically showed under his or her name. The expectation is the each pathology checks these codes because that accuracy and also makes any type of necessary alters prior to case verification. Every codes room then audited ~ sign-out by experienced coding staff. The CPT codes for the technological component space separately bulk verified; this is done beforehand to protect against loss that revenue from late submission of charges, and the password are later corrected after situation sign-out if necessary.


In stimulate to permit for correct up-front billing that immunohistochemical (IHC) stains, the procedure because that ordering IHC was likewise modified slightly. Previously, CPT codes because that IHC had actually to be readjusted after instance verification come comply v the various CPT password assigned to the an initial qualitative IHC mite on a specimen (88342) versus all additional qualitative IHC markers (88341). For each IHC antibody on our roster, at the very least 2 orderable versions to be created: “1st” and also “Add.” for selected antibodies, a “Quant” variation was likewise created. In the new system, when ordering IHC for a given specimen, the pathology orders the first qualitative stain as 1st and any additional qualitative stains together Add; if a quantitative result is to it is in reported, the pathology orders the Quant variation of the stain. This permits the correct IHC CPT codes to be produced up front, through minimal added effort on the part of the pathologist. In part instances, the very same IHC stain is perform on more than one block ~ above the same specimen or part. As only one circumstances of every antibody deserve to be billed every specimen, the duplicate CPT codes should be deleted; this is performed one of two people by the pathology prior to situation verification or by professional coding staff during audit. The very same is true of antibodies that space ordered yet not ultimately contained in the final report.


In order come prepare for the changes in CPT code verification, a number of steps were taken. Number of months prior to implementation, a committee was arranged to regulate the process. Members consisted of pathologists (with depiction from surgical pathology, hematopathology, and also autopsy), department/laboratory administrators, revenue/coding staff, gun room staff, and information an innovation staff. This committee met routinely to plan all aspects of convert to the new process. The committee additionally developed, v the assistance of other subspecialty pathologists, a collection of an extensive job aids include coding guidelines because that the bulk of specimen types that space encountered in our practice. These guidelines were created with the aid of a subscription-based pathology coding hand-operated (Pathology company Coding Handbook8  from the American Pathology Foundation), with adjustments as crucial to complement in-house practices. Prior to the go-live date, a skilled coding consultant (Dennis L. Padget, MBA, CAP, FHFMA, previous publisher that the above-mentioned coding handbook) was lugged in to command introductory cultivate sessions through pathology faculty and also trainees. The coding consultant likewise reviewed and also vetted our in-house coding guidelines, including arbitrarily developed size or number cutoffs for certain specimen types. On and also immediately ~ the go-live date, committee members were obtainable for questions and also troubleshooting, both content related and technical.


Overall, implementation proceeded smoothly. In the adhering to months, the committee focused on encouraging joining by pathologists and also on providing constant updates and also education. Post–sign-out auditing that 100% of in-house instances by experienced coding staff permitted the generation the reports portraying the number and species of alters made and by whom. Newsletters were regularly spread to the department via email, offering explanations, reminders, and also updates based on the most common issues identified. These newsletters were initially released weekly, then monthly, and finally on an as-needed basis. The committee pathologists and coders proceed to offer as suggest persons for questions and also issues indigenous members of the department, and also the project aids have been periodically updated to save up with transforming practices and also to minimization ambiguity.


In terms of self-reported feedback around the establishment of pathologist-verified billing, the responses from pathologists and also their authorized in the procedure has been variable. Our department has pathologists through a wide variety of experience and also training backgrounds. Some pathologists had actually previously been connected in CPT coding at other institutions, and also these people generally adapted to the brand-new system much more readily. Some pathologists without prior exposure to coding likewise willingly embraced the new system, whereas others to be reluctant. The objections raised and their connected arguments and also counterarguments are addressed in detail below.


As the move to pathologist-verified billing to be accompanied by several various other concurrent changes, including separation of professional and also technical billing and switching come a brand-new charge system, exact data illustrating transforms in revenue or costs specifically relating to pathologist involvement are unfortunately unavailable. However, us did observe a far-reaching decrease in the variety of late dues (defined as higher than 5 work from date of service) after the change. In January 2015, prior to the switch, 24.2% (2008 that 8314) that the full surgical pathology charges for the month were late. In January the 2016, several months complying with the switch, only 7.0% (1153 that 16 385) of charges for the month were late, a far-reaching reduction (P 2 analysis). This advancement was attributed mostly to separation the technical and also professional billing (which additionally accounts because that the difference in denominator in between the 2 periods).

See more: What Is The Opposite Of Gold, List Of Opposite Words For Gold At Spellchecker


As accurate CPT codes space the basis because that patient billing and also physician/hospital compensation, that is vital to identify any type of potential worries or areas for improvement. In stimulate to do this, a retrospective analysis was carry out on CPT coding alters for in-house cases during the first 6 months of pathologist-verified billing (May-November 2015) and also during a current 6-month duration (July-December 2016) when the brand-new system had end up being the developed norm. All coding changes were climate categorized by type and direction (changed come a greater code or changed to a lower code), and also were determined as one of two people pathologist initiated or coder initiated. This evaluation included all surgical pathology specimen level password (88300–88309), as well as decalcification; codes regarded IHC, special stains, and also intraoperative consultation were no included. The data room presented in Table 2, and explanations the the most common code adjust categories are provided below. It should be detailed that these are based upon our established coding techniques (based on a subscription-based coding handbook and vetted by a experienced coding consultant), which may differ in part respects indigenous those of various other practices, and are not intended to constitute coding advice.