JUDGE CLAUDE FROLLOOrigin: The Hunchback that Notre Dame (1996)

I really had actually no desire to watch this movie. Negative reviews because that one. For another, it simply didn’t seem feasible for Disney to take something rooted in macabre horror and social injustice together Hunchback and also do… anything through it. And also I was reasonably right. This movie has actually some great art, however lacks any type of memorability. Consisting of Judge Frollo. For some reason, every the internet Geeks think he has one the the best Villain Songs and also is one of the most… sigh… sexy cartoon males together VOTED ~ above by casual Facebook poll. (I worry around humanity.)

Me? i don’t watch the appeal. Nostalgia goggles do him a tires villain through mature themes, but any credit for that goes directly to Victor Hugo, no Disney. I discover myself comparing him come Inspector Javert, one more famous Hugo antagonist (and among my favorite characters of every time). Both are males with no mercy, who execute merciless plot in the name of justice and God. They have actually no compassion, just ambition towards a goal.

You are watching: Villain from hunchback of notre dame

But Frollo just seems robotic. Us only gain a glimpse the what he can be (ex. Making use of words favor “Hell” and “strumpet”, lustful temptation, religious hypocrisy), but none of the goes anywhere. I just can’t take it Frollo seriously together a threat. Javert worked because he was a soldier, not a leader. Javert take away orders indigenous a greater source and also assumes the responsibility for executing them. Frollo constantly seems ignored or at least two inches far from a rebellion. And he blames everyone however himself as soon as things go wrong.


*

Motivation: ns think this is a large factor in the direction of my dislike the Frollo as a villain. His just clear score is to kill gypsies. However we have no idea why. It seems to have actually something to carry out with gypsies not being a pure race, but Wikipedia says most European Romani were Christian.

Does Frollo want to be virtuous? That might explain why he conserves Quasimodo (in the book, this makes more sense since he has actually no household of his own). However nothing he does later on explains it, since he keeps the isolated the rest of his, except for sometimes purposeless visits. Frollo certainly has no attention in sin atonement, since he’s got a Hitler woody out for those gypsies the remainder of the movie. And also the archdeacon — the “voice the God” — keeps admonishing him for his transgressions.

Does he want power? Doesn’t seem to, never shows any ambition for it. He’s already got it, anyway.

Does he desire Esmeralda? Clearly, yes, yet to what end does he go to get her? He death her whole family ~ above a city-wide manhunt. Then once he has her, he requirements that one of two people she marries that or gets melted at the stake. What is his logic? If she say yes, he’s going to have to describe to the citizens why the same person he tried come burn together a witch is his brand-new wife. If she claims no, then no one gets what they want. In the publication (also according to Wikipedia, for this reason mileage might vary), Frollo experience the very same jealousy, the same problem of church vs. Lust. Yet that makes more sense since he’s an archdeacon, not a judge.


*

Character Strengths: The movie provides it look favor Frollo is in charge of the totality of Paris. I understand this can’t be true (another continually error against him). He doesn’t also do any type of judging. Is he even a judge? the watches the “Festival the Fools” because… he’s compelled to? Why? he doesn’t have a duty to take it in it.

He teaches Quasimodo part alphabet, some spiritual knowledge because… why? Is he going to college later? the seems favor he’s a windy figure, one the captain the the guards answers to, but he’s plainly not a town leader. Not a an excellent one, in ~ least. Also Disney isn’t sure who this personality is. They’re make the efforts to shove one persona into another’s body. I’m much more worried about Frollo’s equine than Frollo.


*

Evilness: If ns was providing individual ratings for each criteria, Frollo’s evil variable would get five stars. In the an initial scene he’s searching down a gypsy because that no reason various other than too much prejudice. That kills her (somewhat accidentally), then discovers she was moving a baby. As soon as he discovers it’s deformed (although who knows what that would have actually done v it if it was normal) he practically throws the abomination in a well (which would have actually poisoned the city — quite job almost breaking it, hero). However by some divine inspiration, he transforms his mind and also decides to preventive him. Climate LOCKS the IN A BELL TOWER because that THE remainder OF HIS LIFE. That’s the an initial five minutes.

There’s no an inch of goodness or mercy on this guy. He rule through magnificent right, yet is completely hypocritical around it, only selecting to follow the rules when they suit his needs. He claims to have morals and values, yet ignores them as soon as his basic desires increase (murdering civilization to uncover gypsies, threaten Esmerelda to be his slave). He’s a sociopath — he feels guilty for what he’s done, but has no compunction around doing it again, choose a pedophile. His fearsomeness comes from the truth that of every the villains, he’s the most realistic.


*

Tools: Frollo’s got the city’s military on his side, but their allegiance appears tenuous in ~ best. The city riots and also everything goes come pot. His one necessary subordinate betrays the midway through, who then leads the gypsies and citizens against his government soldiers. It’s anarchy, and all Frollo cares around is acquiring into the cathedral.


*

Complement come the Hero: Another big problem is the Quasimodo is together discombobulated as his antagonist. He falls into the Disney Princess trap, in that all he wants is… more. Frollo’s preserved Quasimodo concealed away this entire time, however when he’s torture at the Festival of Fools, that appears totally justified. It’s not until Esmeralda reflects up that he gets called out. Climate Quasimodo gets supplied like a device to find her. (This component isn’t that poor actually).

The trouble is that Quasimodo has all the personality the a wet blanket. That looks choose a Batman villain and also acts favor a Broadway superstar. Ns guess there’s one “ugly-on-the-inside” point going on, but Frollo’s not that attractive in the first place (unless you think NChick). However at least he’s not a villain that simply floats out there, with no connection to the hero.


Fatal Flaw: You would certainly think the his fatal defect would have actually been his self-righteousness, or his hypocrisy in spite of his guilt (repeats that the “mea culpa” test to that effect). Or I could make a joke about his inability to cave onto stone structures. But the movie would have you believe that it’s due to the fact that Quasimodo make friends. Castle both fall, however while Frollo falls into Hell the pool of molten copper and burnt cathedral, Phoebus captures Quasimodo (an action which should have yanked his arms out of his sockets).

Maybe there’s miscellaneous to that — tying right into the “what provides a monster and what renders a man” theme. I guess the trouble is that Frollo is a complex character, but Disney attempts to make his downfall the result of one activity (or inaction) to keep it basic for the kids. At the very least it’s a little much more theatrical 보다 the book ending, through swords and Latin chanting and also fire.

Except that it’s preceded by a rip-off of the beauty & the Beast crowd fight v those fucking gargoyles.


Method that Defeat/Death: after ~ Frollo operation up the cathedral tower, Quasimodo disarms the (once he numbers out the movie’s moral) climate flees through Esmeralda. Frollo finds him hanging turn off the roof and tries come chop him v a sword. Quasimodo tarzans away, yet Frollo catches up. Then because that some factor he throws his cloak over Quasimodo’s head come knock him turn off balance. This backfires as Quasimodo bring away the coat and also they both fall.

Esmeralda holds ~ above Quasimodo’s hand if Frollo regains his poise ~ above a statue outcropping. He holds his sword up favor a samurai warrior.

See more: Sb-17 Which Of The Following Must You Do When Anchoring At Night? ?

Then the stone cracks and also Frollo, who has the worst balance in the people (the stone didn’t even move!) falls off, however grabs top top the statue. The eye glow red (I don’t know why, the statue simply seems favor a cat or something, no the judging eyes of Jesus), the stone breaks, and also he drops into the surface of the sun.


Final Rating: 3 stars

PREVIOUS ANALYSES:Scar (The Lion King)Prince john (Robin Hood)Edgar (The Aristocats)Ratigan (The an excellent Mouse Detective)Maleficent (Sleeping Beauty)


Eric J. Juneau

Eric Juneau is a software program engineer and novelist on his lunch breaks. In 2016, his very first novel, Merm-8, was published by eTreasures. He stays in, to be born in, and also refuses to leave, Minnesota. Girlfriend can uncover him talking around movies, video clip games, and also Disney princesses in ~ http://www.ptcouncil.net whereby he details his journey to become a resources A Author.Read posts by Eric J. Juneau