Those who defended slavery increased to the an obstacle set soon by the Abolitionists. The defenders the slavery included economics, history, religion, legality, social good, and even humanitarianism, to more their arguments.

You are watching: What argument did southerners give in support of slave labor?


Defenders of slavery suggested that the sudden end to the slave economic climate would have had actually a profound and killing economic impact in the south where dependency on slave labor was the foundation of their economy. The cotton economic climate would collapse. The tobacco crop would dry in the fields. Rice would certainly cease gift profitable.

Defenders the slavery argued that if all the slaves were freed, there would be widespread unemployment and also chaos. This would cause uprisings, bloodshed, and also anarchy. Castle pointed to the mob"s "rule the terror" throughout the French transformation and suggested for the extension of the status quo, i m sorry was offering for affluence and stability because that the slaveholding class and also for all complimentary people who appreciated the bounty the the slave society.


*
Some slaveholders believed that african Americans to be biologically worse to your masters. During the 1800s, this arguement to be taken rather seriously, even in clinical circles.

Defenders the slavery suggested that slavery had existed throughout background and to be the natural state that mankind. The Greeks had slaves, the Romans had actually slaves, and the English had slavery until really recently.

Defenders of slavery detailed that in the Bible, Abraham had actually slaves. They point to the Ten Commandments, noting the "Thou shalt no covet her neighbor"s house, ... No one his manservant, nor his maidservant." In the new Testament, Paul returned a runaway slave, Philemon, to his master, and, although slavery was prevalent throughout the roman world, Jesus never spoke out versus it.

Defenders of slavery turned come the courts, who had actually ruled, with the Dred Scott Decision, the all blacks — not just slaves — had no legal standing as persons in our courts — they were property, and the Constitution safeguarded slave-holders" rights to their property.

Defenders the slavery argued that the college was divine, and that it brought Christianity come the heathen from throughout the ocean. Slavery was, follow to this argument, a an excellent thing because that the enslaved. Man C. Calhoun said, "Never before has the black gyeongju of central Africa, from the dawn of history to the current day, attained a problem so civilized and so improved, not only physically, however morally and intellectually."


Defenders of slavery said that through comparison through the bad of Europe and the workers in the north states, that servants were far better cared for. They claimed that their owners would certainly protect and assist them when they to be sick and aged, uneven those who, once fired from their work, were left come fend helplessly for themselves.

James Thornwell, a minister, composed in 1860, "The parties in this problem are not just Abolitionists and also slaveholders, they room Atheists, Socialists, Communists, Red Republicans, Jacobins ~ above the one side and also the friends of order and regulated liberty on the other."


*
The violence the Nat Turner"s 1831 slave revolt frightened numerous southern slaveholders. Together unrest was supplied by numerous as a factor to proceed slavery.

When a culture forms around any type of institution, as the southern did roughly slavery, it will certainly formulate a collection of debates to assistance it. The Southerners held ever before firmer come their arguments as the political tensions in the nation drew us ever closer to the civil War.

The peculiar Institution Quiz


What invention led to the boosted concentration of slavery in the South?Cotton ginTractorRifleClockWhich that the following was not included in the slave Codes?Rules because that educating slavesRules for punishing slavesRules for feeding slavesRules for servant marriagesWhich that the adhering to was valued by men in the southerly aristocracy?GreedBeautyHonorPietyWhat is the term for a master setting a slave free?EmancipationManumissionReleaseAbolitionWhich two guys led servant revolts throughout the 1800s?Frederick Douglass and Denmark VesseyGabriel Prosser and Frederick DouglassNat Turner and Eli WhitneyDenmark Vessey and Nat TurnerWhich that the complying with was not a Southern dispute in donate of slavery?ReligionEconomyLegalityClimate

*

A background of the Defense of slavery in AmericaA book review the Larry Tise"s Proslavery: A history of The Defense of enslavement In America. Despite this testimonial is fairly short, it does current some the the frighten reasoning offered to justify slavery, consisting of the regarded approbation the slavery discovered in the Bible.

Report damaged link


George Fitzhugh, 1806-81
George Fitzhugh"s two books advocating slavery aided polarize Northerners and Southerners on the concern of slavery. Fitzhugh preserved that all labor is essentially slavery and also that the "slavery" of free workers is much more cruel than the finish slavery of blacks. There are links to digital versions that his books.

Report damaged link


Justification of Slavery
The American Memory program at the Library that Congress ensures that we don"t forget our nations past — the an excellent and the bad. This perform of attached articles, pamphlets, and also books leader to one extensive selection of justifications for slavery. Read the words of contemporary Southern slaveholders to check out why lock thought enslavement was right.

Report damaged link


Contemporary White Opinions the Slavery
How go a Southerner feel around daily life with slaves? exactly how did would one feel about a violent revolt? girlfriend can uncover out in their own words. Southern Carolina"s details Highway has provided a list of links from folks down in Dixie before the civil War. Find out first-hand what they thought of enslavement here.

Report broken link


The best of holding slaves is plainly established in the divine Scriptures, both by precept and also example. — R. Furman, D.D., Baptist, of southern Carolina (19th-Century Reverend)Learn More...

See more: Two Stars Of The Same Spectral Class Must Have The Same, Exam 4 Flashcards

Report broken link


How walk southerners justify slavery? This short but fine written summary from the BBC outlines the significant lines that reasoning provided to rationalize enslaving other people for benefit as ethically defensible.Learn More...

Report broken link


If you choose our content, please share the on social media!

*
*

Tweet
*
*
*

*


Tweet