In thing 3 or 4 of Black Butler, Sebastian is making use of a cell phone phone once talking come those guys who space holding Ciel captive.

Is this a wrong by the writer or something else? Isn"t Black Butler in the 1800s?


*

*

In the manga chapter 27 web page 41, it was displayed that Ciel Phantomhive to be born in 1875. Googling v the crucial phrase "the first cell phone" tells us that the very first mobile-phone was developed in 1973 by Motorola, i beg your pardon is 100 years after Ciel to be born.

You are watching: When does black butler take place

Since Ciel was 13 (12 during the an initial 14 chapters) in the story, cellphones should not have actually existed. Thus, choose lentinant stated in his comment, that is likely that the story takes place in an alternate reality.


*

*

In illustration 10, they go to a Frost fair on the Thames, the critical of which was in 1814.Jack the Ripper"s murders were in 1888.Queen Victoria reigned from 1839-1901.Presumably, some research either wasn"t done, or 100% historic accuracy to be ignored in favor of including all the elements the author wanted in the series.

It"s a quite silly collection too, for this reason what does that matter? Can"t complain about dates not lining increase when human being run through stone walls and also get spend by fire because that several secs without lasting burns.


*

They say the the 2 brothers in the tower were imprisoned in 1483, and also when Ciel talks around it, he describes this occasion as having actually taken location 400 years ago, so the must"ve remained in the 1850s and also plus.


As lentinant has actually commented above, Black Butler does not have actually a set time. The place is established as England and the era is clearly Victorian because of the architecture, theme, clothes and general behavior. But as it is a fantasy genre manga/ptcouncil.net, over there are several inconsistencies such as chainsaws, cell-phones and semiautomatic tools that space incorporated.

In most fantasy themed works, history is payment homage and is eluded to quite than portrayed accurately.


While looking up "cell phones" will certainly come up with 1973, Sebastian was not utilizing a cell phone. Cell phones and also the phone he provided is different, and also cell phones were no invented ago then. However, the did have phones and it was designed in 1876.


I haven"t read the manga, however as pointed out in one more answer, the couldn"t have been a cellphone. As displayed in the ptcouncil.net, the isn"t a cellphone and also they quite can"t adjust the plot the much.

If I"m right, this all was as soon as Ciel was captured.


desire to enhance this post? add citations from reputable sources by editing and enhancing the post. Short articles with unsourced content might be edited or deleted.
Black Butler does take place as the says. Browsing up "When was the very first phone invented?" will certainly return in march 10, 1876.

See more: All Arteries Carry Oxygen-Rich Blood, Whereas Veins Carry Oxygen-Poor Blood.

I psychic in the second episode that the ptcouncil.net, they had actually one that the phones that are shown in the images, however it wasn"t a cabinet phone. Ns just had it in a bag to assist transport it.


Highly active question. Knife 10 call (not counting the combination bonus) in order come answer this question. The reputation necessity helps safeguard this concern from spam and also non-answer activity.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged black-butler or questioning your own question.


What is Sebastian's catchphrase 'A Phantomhive butler who can't execute this much isn't worth his salt' in Japanese
site architecture / logo © 2021 ridge Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. Rev2021.10.19.40496


your privacy

By clicking “Accept all cookies”, girlfriend agree stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose info in accordance v our Cookie Policy.