You are watching: Who is rab in half blood prince
There were 2 years in between the publishing of Prince and Hallows throughout which the identification of the locket theif may have been uncertain. Walk the take care of Potter pan deduce R.A.B."s identity? do we know this from statements the were definitely made before the publication of Hallows? were there any type of interesting alternative theories? Or walk the fans quickly settle right into a consensus that the locket thief was Regulus?
improve this concern
inquiry Apr 2 "20 at 1:17
30.9k1616 yellow badges120120 silver badges345345 bronze title
add a comment |
1 price 1
active oldest Votes
With a fanbase as big as bother Potter"s is, there"s never ever a complete consensus on anything, of food - but pretty lot from the start "RAB = Regulus Black" to be the frontrunner theory, with only tiny pockets of fans speculating something else.
Take a look, because that example, at this Mugglenet write-up published only 4 days after the relax of the HBP, which nice prescient both in the general and specific details the RAB"s identity:
Now the I have actually laid the end the criteria I believe our mysterious R. A. B. Has to follow, I will certainly state that I believe the human being is: Regulus Black, Sirius’ younger brother...
I think Regulus more than likely had much more courage 보다 Sirius offered him credit for. I have a emotion that Regulus uncovered himself in a situation similar to what Draco Malfoy got himself right into in HBP. Regulus probably did get scared, but unlike Draco, he refused to do what Voldemort was asking him to do and actually do the efforts to assist the future vanquisher destroy Voldemort. The takes a the majority of guts to go versus Voldemort, and I have actually a feeling Regulus knew he might never hide indigenous Voldemort, and also if he was going to die, that did not want to perform it cowardly yet was walk to try to perform something that would be terrible to Voldemort.
I think the is likely that harry will involved figure out who the secret R. A. B. Is with either Sirius’ home or Kreacher; both of which he has actually conveniently inherited. I think the Harry will certainly again find assist in a human being that that was no expecting.
Or this 2006 past Hogwarts article, which guesses not only at RAB"s identification but virtually every detail of just how the locket plot would ultimately go down:
So, wherein is the actual locket now? Regulus" keep in mind says he intends to damage it as quickly as that can, however we don"t understand for sure that that did.
If it"s anywhere, you"d doubt it"s someplace in Grimauld Place, whereby we assume Regulus lived v his parents. In bother Potter and also the stimulate of the Phoenix, once they room cleaning the end the parlor in Grimauld Place, a locket is mentioned, but only briefly... It"s a good chance the locket Harry experienced in the cabinet in Grimauld place was the locket. But, wherein is the now?
Some fans believe Kreacher has it.
Even the civilization who argued versus it go so largely on the grounds the "it"s also obvious" or "it"ll it is in unsatisfying" quite than having alternative theories to propose.
Take, for example, this respectable 2005 post from a "RAB is not Regulus Black" supporter:
The idea the Regulus black color is RAB is by far the most renowned conclusion and also there seems to be numerous things that pop up confirming the theory.
Hands up, i don’t have any sort the argument versus Regulus black being RAB, apart from my gut emotion that it’s so apparent that it can’t be true.
Or this at an early stage 2006 forum post:
I never thought Regulus black was RAB. That would be would be too much in your face approach, unRowlinglike. She place something in your challenge at very first but always debunks that afterwards
(And shoutout come this person, who while arguing against "RAB = Regulus Black" managed to randomly assumption: v a pretty large plot allude involving Kreacher):
No method is that Regalus. It simply seems so... Stupid and unlikley. Just due to the fact that his initials fit... However i think KReacher to be there and also was compelled to drink the potion, and also that"s why the is a small mad. It to be too lot for a House-elf come take.
A few places opened up themselves up to fun alternative theories (I think, "RAB is Dumbledore, time traveling to the future" is mine favorite) but none got much traction amongst the broader fanbase.
See more: Can I Get Free Ringback Tones For Straight Talk Android, Free Ringback Tones For Straight Talk
In the weeks and also days counting down to DH"s release, the theory went even much more mainstream, arriving on many non-HP media sites. It"s safe to say that by DH"s release, the only human being not expecting this twist were the ones who either didn"t follow speculation at all or had a niche alternating theory.